The EU’s top court has thrown out an Austrian reference on Malta’s Bill 55 without deciding whether the law is lawful. Malta’s shield against foreign player-loss judgments stays in force, and the pressure now shifts to the Commission’s infringement case.
Court sidesteps the legality of Malta’s player-loss shield
The Court of Justice of the European Union has declined to say whether Malta’s Bill 55 is compatible with EU law. It rejected the Austrian reference in the Spielerschutz Sigma case as inadmissible. The judges found that the Vienna court did not need an answer to decide the case before it.
The Vienna dispute was not directly about player losses. It concerned a legal adviser’s liability to Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder. In an opinion dated 5 July 2023, the adviser described Article 56A as manifestly contrary to EU law. The opinion also expected first-instance enforcement proceedings in Malta to finish within six months.
Events went the other way. On 1 August 2023 a Maltese court relied on Article 56A to refuse recognition and enforcement under the Brussels I bis Regulation. Those proceedings were funded by Spielerschutz Sigma.
The outcome follows the Advocate General’s April opinion. Because the reference failed on admissibility, the judges never addressed his alternative view on the merits.
Malta added the provision to its Gaming Act in June 2023 through Bill 55. Before the Court, Malta’s government defended Article 56A as a declaratory provision. In its view, the provision helps Maltese courts apply the public policy ground in Article 45(1)(a) of Brussels I bis.
The shield survives, but Brussels keeps its case open
For MGA licensees with exposure in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, the practical effect is continuity. Maltese courts can still refuse to enforce Austrian and German judgments that order Malta-licensed operators to repay players’ losses. Thousands of claims are funded by litigation financiers. Spielerschutz Sigma has won numerous judgments for its clients against Malta-licensed operators and is trying to enforce them in Malta.
Two other recent judgments bear on the same conflict. In Case C-440/23, decided on 16 April 2026, the Court held that a member state may ban certain online gambling services licensed elsewhere in the EU. It may also attach civil-law consequences to that ban. In the Mr Green ruling (C-198/24) of 21 May 2026, the Court ruled on European Account Preservation Orders. A court weighing urgency may consider a law in the debtor’s home state that could hinder enforcement. That application covered the Malta-licensed operator’s accounts in Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and Sweden.
The legal question therefore remains open. In its infringement case, the Commission argued that the law obliges Maltese courts to turn away, as a rule, judgments from other member states against Malta-licensed gaming firms. In the Commission’s view, protecting the sector from cross-border lawsuits erodes the mutual trust on which justice cooperation in the EU rests. Earlier coverage suggested it was waiting for this judgment before acting. With no ruling from Luxembourg, any escalation of the infringement case now rests with the Commission.
Source material
- Press release No 167/26: Judgment of the Court in Case C-683/24 Spielerschutz Sigma (Court of Justice of the European Union)
- June infringements package: key decisions (European Commission Representation in Malta)
- ECJ sidesteps ruling on compatibility of Malta’s Bill 55 with EU law (iGaming Business)
- EU court declines to rule on Malta’s Bill 55 in Spielerschutz Sigma case (European Gaming)
The post CJEU declines to rule on Malta’s Bill 55, leaving the next move to the European Commission appeared first on CasinoBeats.
The EU’s top court has thrown out an Austrian reference on Malta’s Bill 55 without deciding whether the law is lawful. Malta’s shield against foreign player-loss judgments stays in force, and the pressure now shifts to the Commission’s infringement case.
The post CJEU declines to rule on Malta’s Bill 55, leaving the next move to the European Commission appeared first on CasinoBeats.